SEO vs PPC: When Channel Drives Better Results

TL;DR:

• Use SEO when you want sustainable, compounding traffic and can play the long game.
• Use PPC (paid search and social ads) when you need leads or sales this quarter and have tight control over targeting and budget.
• In most accounts we review, the highest ROI comes from a smart mix of both, not a coin toss between them.
• Short sales cycle or time bound campaign? PPC usually leads. Long buying cycle or category creation? SEO tends to win.

Why this question never really goes away

In almost every marketing meeting, someone eventually asks, “So, seo vs ppc where should we put the next dollar?” The CMO wants growth, the finance lead wants a clear forecast, and your team just wants a plan that won’t get ripped up next quarter. If you’ve ever felt stuck in that conversation, you’re not alone. We hear it from municipalities, utilities, ecommerce brands, and B2B service firms every single month.

The truth: you’re not choosing a winner for all time. You’re choosing the right channel for this goal, this budget, and this timeline. Once you see SEO and PPC as tools in one toolbox instead of rival teams, the decision gets a lot less stressful.

SEO and PPC in plain language

Let’s keep this simple and human.

• SEO (search engine optimization) is the work that helps your pages show up in the organic listings on Google and Bing. No click fee, but it takes effort, content, and time.
• PPC (pay per click) is when you run ads on platforms like Google Ads and Meta Ads. You pay each time someone clicks, in exchange for immediate visibility.

Both can send highly qualified visitors to your site. The real question is when SEO should lead, when PPC should lead, and how they can support each other instead of fighting over budget.

SEO: pros, cons, and where it wins

SEO pros

• Compounding traffic over time. Strong content and technical foundations can keep driving clicks for months or years with no media bill.
• High trust. Many users skip ads and click organic results first, especially for research heavy decisions.
• Great for information heavy journeys. If buyers ask lots of questions before they contact sales, SEO backed content can do a lot of the heavy lifting.
• Supports the whole funnel. From “what is net zero?” to “electrical contractor near me,” SEO can meet people at every stage.

SEO cons

• Slow to start. New content can take months to rank, especially in crowded categories.
• Harder to throttle. You can’t just flip a switch and get double the traffic next week.
• Algorithm volatility. Google updates can shuffle rankings, which is why a steady, quality first approach matters.

Best situations for SEO

• You have a long buying cycle (construction, professional services, B2B SaaS, infrastructure projects).
• You want to build an asset you own, not just rent impressions.
• You’re building a category or public understanding (public safety, new regulations, climate action, new product types).

If this sounds like your world, you may want SEO at the centre of your strategy, supported by specialist SEO services.

PPC: pros, cons, and where it wins

PPC pros

• Speed. You can go from concept to traffic in days, not months.
• Pinpoint targeting. Reach people by keyword, location, interests, job title, income, and more.
• Control. Set daily budgets, bid caps, and schedules and change them as results come in.
• Testing power. Paid campaigns are perfect for message and creative testing before you roll out big brand investments.

PPC cons

• You’re renting attention. Turn off the budget and traffic drops to zero.
• Costs can climb. Competitive industries see higher cost per click (CPC), especially for bottom of funnel terms.
• Platforms change often. Google Ads, Meta Ads, and LinkedIn roll out new rules, policies, and features regularly.

Best situations for PPC

• You have a time bound campaign (program launch, bylaw consultation, grant intake window, seasonal promo).
• You need predictable lead volume this quarter.
• You want to validate a new offer or audience quickly before investing in SEO and content at scale.

This is where focused PPC and media buying can pay off fast.

A balanced plan treats PPC as the laboratory and SEO as the long term growth engine. Your best ad copy, high converting queries, and landing page insights should inform your website and content strategy.

SEO vs PPC: which is better for your goals?

The honest answer to “seo vs ppc which is better?” is: it depends what you’re trying to achieve this year.

Goal 1: “We need leads or online sales this quarter”

• Primary channel: PPC (search + social).
• Why: You can reach high intent searchers and in market audiences immediately.
• Support from SEO: Make sure landing pages load fast, answer key questions, and align with search intent this also helps organic performance later.

Goal 2: “We want to own our category over the next 1 to 3 years”

• Primary channel: SEO and content.
• Why: You need hundreds or thousands of touchpoints across the buyer journey, not just last click conversions.
• Support from PPC: Use search and social ads to test headlines, offers, and topics before turning them into cornerstone content.

Goal 3: “We need awareness and behaviour change”

Municipal campaigns, public safety initiatives, and utilities often sit here.

• Primary mix: PPC (search + social) plus SEO backed content hub.
• Why: You have a story to tell, a deadline, and specific audiences PPC gets you scale, while SEO ensures that when people search later, they still find you.

For a deeper strategy conversation, many teams start with our ROI Framework, which links channel choices directly to revenue and impact.

Budget, timeline, and risk: a simple framework

When we help clients choose between ppc vs seo, we look at three lenses:

1. Timeline: When do you actually need results?
2. Budget flexibility: Can you front load investment or do you need month by month control?
3. Risk tolerance: Are you okay with a long build, or do you need fast feedback?

A simple way to think about it:

• Short timeline + low risk tolerance: Lean on PPC, supported by quick on page SEO wins.
• Longer timeline + medium risk tolerance: Lead with SEO, using PPC to support priority campaigns.
• Mixed timeline (some now, some later): Split budget and let PPC insights shape your SEO roadmap.

How this looks in practice

Scenario 1 – Regional utility with a 4 month rebate program. A Western Canadian utility came to us with a fixed deadline: fill a limited rebate program before funds expired. Timeline and risk tolerance were both tight, so we recommended putting roughly 80% of the budget into PPC (Google Search + Meta) to drive form fills immediately, and 20% into SEO clean up on the existing program pages. Within the first 90 days, paid search delivered the bulk of conversions, while SEO improvements kept the page ranking and driving organic sign ups long after the ads were paused.

Scenario 2 – B2B services firm planning for the next 18 months. A professional services client had modest lead goals in the short term but ambitious growth targets over three years. We flipped the mix: about 70% of the budget went into SEO and content (category explainers, service pages, and case studies), with 30% allocated to tightly targeted PPC on their most profitable keywords. PPC campaigns validated which messages and offers converted best, then those learnings fed directly into long‑form content and landing pages that now drive most of their inbound leads without ongoing ad spend.

Industry benchmarks also show why it rarely makes sense to pick only one channel. Across many sectors, search studies find that organic search drives roughly half of all trackable visits, with paid search adding another quarter on top together accounting for the majority of site traffic. Organic vs paid click share reports are a useful reference point when you’re modeling different budget scenarios.

Whether you choose a search engine optimization agency also providing PPC services or a 360 digital marketing agency, be sure conversion tracking is solid. Google’s own Analytics documentation is a good reference point, and a conversion ready analytics setup is part of how we work with clients from day one.

FAQs:

“If we rank #1 organically, should we still run PPC on that keyword?”

Often, yes especially for high value branded terms and core services. We regularly see branded search ads deliver very low cost per click and protect against competitors bidding on your name. Running both can increase total click share and keep you from losing traffic to a rival ad sitting on top of your organic result.

“What’s a healthy budget split between SEO and PPC?”

There’s no single right answer, but as a rough starting point:

• New websites or brands: 60–70% PPC, 30–40% SEO.
• Established brands with solid traffic: 40–50% PPC, 50–60% SEO.
• Mature, search heavy brands: 20–40% PPC, 60–80% SEO.

Whatever split you start with, build a simple model using realistic performance assumptions. Many industry studies suggest an average Google Ads return on ad spend around 2:1, with roughly 3.3:1 as a median and 4:1–5:1 considered strong performance across accounts; ROAS benchmarks like these can help you sanity check your targets before you lock in budgets.

We often rebalance that mix every quarter based on what’s working.

“Does running PPC help or hurt our SEO?”

PPC doesn’t directly change your organic rankings Google keeps its ads and ranking algorithms separate. In most accounts, though, the two channels support each other. Search ads can:

• Generate fast traffic that exposes technical or UX issues you can fix for both paid and organic visitors.
• Show you which keywords, messages, and offers convert best before you invest in long form content.
• Increase total click share when your brand appears in both the ad slots and the top organic positions.

The flip side is that weak landing pages or confusing offers will drag down both PPC and SEO performance. We usually treat ads as a rapid feedback loop that helps us improve the organic experience, not as a substitute for it.

“What if our budget is too small to do both?”

With a tight budget, you don’t need a 50/50 split you need a focused sequence. For many organizations, that looks like:

• Investing first in a few critical SEO fundamentals: fixing technical issues, clarifying key service pages, and setting up analytics and conversion tracking.
• Running a very targeted PPC campaign on your highest intent keywords or audiences instead of trying to cover everything.

As those campaigns start generating revenue or participation, you can reinvest a portion of the results into expanding content, new landing pages, or additional campaigns. The goal is to prove the mix in 90 days, then scale what’s working instead of guessing.

“Can we pause SEO for a while and just run ads?”

You can, but think of SEO like fitness. Stop training for six months and you don’t go right back to where you left off. If budget gets tight, we’d rather slim SEO down to a lean, focused program than stop completely.

How Setsail can help you choose with confidence

At Setsail, we work with municipalities, utilities, B Corps, and high growth brands across North America. The pattern is the same: leaders aren’t asking for “more traffic,” they’re asking for revenue, participation, and measurable impact.

That’s why our team doesn’t treat SEO and PPC as separate silos. We connect your search strategy to a clear ROI model:

• Vision Mapping: Turn broad goals into specific search and campaign objectives.
• Marketing Lab: Use PPC to test audiences, offers, and messages.
• Scale & Optimize: Invest in SEO and high performing campaigns based on what the data shows.

‍

‍