Signs Your Business Needs a Website Redesign

Your site looks “fine,” but sales are flat. Your team is swapping screenshots of competitors’ shiny new sites in Slack. And someone just said the words, “Maybe we just need a full Website Redesign.”

If you’ve been through one before, you already know: redesigns can either be a growth lever or an expensive way to tank your SEO and conversion rate for six months.

This guide walks you through what growing businesses should actually do before, during, and after a redesign especially if your site is a key driver of leads or ecommerce revenue. You’ll get a practical redesign checklist, ecommerce specific tips, and the decision points that matter most for real world performance.

TL;DR:

• Redesign when you’ve hit a ceiling on performance, not just because the site feels “old.”
• Start with goals, data, and benchmarks so you can tell if the new site is actually better.
• Use a clear website redesign checklist across analytics, UX, SEO, content, and dev.
• For ecommerce, obsess over product discovery, cart, and checkout, not just the homepage hero.
• Plan post launch testing and optimization launch day is the starting line, not the finish line.

When is it actually time to redesign your website?

Redesigns often start with feelings: “Our site looks dated” or “Marketing says the brand has evolved.” Feelings are valid, but they don’t pay the ad bill.

Here are healthier triggers for a redesign:

• Conversion is stuck or dropping even as traffic holds steady or grows.
• Your offer or business model changed (new product lines, subscriptions, new geos) and the site no longer matches how you sell.
• Technical limitations in your CMS or theme are blocking basic improvements, experiments, or integrations.
• Core Web Vitals and page speed are poor and hard to fix without structural changes.
• Your team can’t update the site quickly without dev help, slowing campaigns and product launches.

If two or more of these are true for you, a planned redesign with clear ROI goals probably beats endless band-aid fixes.

Step 1: Set goals and baseline your current performance

A redesign without a baseline is just an opinion contest. Before you sketch a single wireframe, get clear on three numbers:

• Traffic (sessions by channel and device)
• Conversion rate (lead form, demo request, purchase)
• Revenue per visitor or lead quality

Pull this from tools like Google Analytics 4, your CRM, and ad platforms. If you don’t have clean tracking, that’s assignment #1.

Then define success in plain language, for example:

• “Increase qualified demo requests by 30% within six months of launch.”
• “Improve ecommerce checkout completion rate from 55% to 65%.”

Write these into your project brief. If you’re working with an agency, these targets should drive designs, copy decisions, and the conversion focused page templates they recommend.

Step 2: Build a realistic website redesign checklist

Most teams underestimate the number of decisions inside a redesign. A clear website redesign checklist keeps the project moving and reduces “Oh no, we forgot…” moments a week before launch.

1. Analytics, tracking, and data

• Audit current tracking (GA4 events, goals, ecommerce tracking, pixels, tags).
• List the conversions that matter and how they’ll be tracked post launch.
• Plan URL changes and redirects so you don’t lose data continuity.
• Document pre launch benchmarks for key pages (home, category, product, pricing, contact).

Resources like Google’s own Core Web Vitals documentation are worth a review here, especially if you rely on organic traffic.

2. Brand, positioning, and messaging

• Clarify who your best customers are and why they choose you.
• Write or refine your core value proposition and proof points.
• Decide which offers you want to emphasize (demo, quote, free trial, quiz, etc.).
• Align messaging with your brand and creative direction.

3. UX, IA, and user journeys

• Map primary user journeys: new visitor, returning lead, existing customer.
• Reorganize your information architecture (navigation, categories, footer) around those journeys.
• Sketch simple wireframes for key templates before jumping into high fidelity designs.
• Validate decisions with quick user tests or stakeholder walkthroughs.

The UX research work from firms like Nielsen Norman Group is a good reality check when opinions start to clash.

4. SEO and site structure

• Export all existing URLs and rankings.
• Decide which pages to keep, merge, or retire.
• Map every old URL to a new one with a 301 redirect plan.
• Keep top performing content as intact as possible (title, H1, internal links).
• Plan internal linking between high intent pages and supporting content, like your SEO driven blog posts.

5. Content, copy, and assets

• List every page template and the content it needs (headlines, body, CTAs, FAQs).
• Audit existing content for accuracy, performance, and brand alignment.
• Plan new assets: photography, video, icons, and downloadable resources.
• Decide who owns each piece and deadlines for drafts and approvals.

6. Development, QA, and launch planning

• Choose your platform (e.g., Shopify, WordPress, Webflow) based on current and near term needs.
• Set non negotiable performance targets (page speed, mobile responsiveness, accessibility).
• Build a QA checklist: forms, search, filters, logins, localization, tracking, redirects.
• Plan your launch window around traffic cycles and paid campaign schedules.

How long a website redesign takes (and what it costs)

One of the first questions your leadership team will ask is, “How long will this take, and how much will it cost?” While every website redesign is unique, most projects for growing businesses fall into three patterns.

Light refresh (4–8 weeks)

This is typically a UX and visual update on top of your existing platform. You might refine navigation, modernize the homepage, update a handful of key templates, and improve page speed without changing your CMS or rewriting every page. Timelines are shortest when content is mostly reused and decisions are centralized. Budget wise, expect something in the low five figures, depending on the number of templates and integrations.

Full redesign (8–16 weeks)

A full redesign usually includes updated information architecture, new page templates for core journeys, refreshed copy, and a stronger visual system. There’s time for UX research, SEO planning, and development work beyond simple theme tweaks. These projects often run in the mid five figures to low six figures for B2B, SaaS, and ecommerce brands, especially when they include content support, analytics implementation, and robust QA.

Complex rebuild (4–6+ months)

Complex projects combine a redesign with replatforming, heavy integrations, or custom application work think multi language sites, complicated quoting flows, or deep CRM and product database integrations. Timelines extend because discovery, technical architecture, migration, and content production all take longer. Budgets typically land in the six figure range and should explicitly include strategy, UX research, SEO, development, integration work, and post launch support.

Regardless of size, most delays come from slow decision making and content bottlenecks, not just development. When you scope your project, align early on which tier you’re in, what “must ship” on day one, and which nice to have items can move into a phase two roadmap.

Special section: ecommerce website redesign priorities

If you run an online store, a “pretty” redesign that hurts product discovery or checkout flow hits revenue right away. Your ecommerce website redesign should focus on a few high leverage areas first.

Product discovery and search

• Cleaner category structure and filters that match how customers shop in real life.
• Site search that handles typos, synonyms, and merchandising rules.
• Clear product details: specs, sizing, compatibility, reviews, and social proof.

UX studies from groups like Baymard Institute show that small friction points in filters and search can meaningfully reduce add to cart rates.

Cart and checkout flow

• Guest checkout, plus clear benefits for creating an account.
• Transparent pricing (shipping, taxes, fees) early in the flow.
• Payment methods your buyers actually use (e.g., Shop Pay, Apple Pay, PayPal).
• Trust signals: security messaging, guarantees, returns policy links.

Operations and integrations

• Inventory, shipping, and order management integrations that reduce manual work.
• Email and SMS flows synced with your new site structure.
• Post purchase surveys and analytics that feed back into product and marketing decisions.

In short: measure the redesign by impact on add to cart, checkout completion, and repeat purchase rate not just how your new PDP looks in a design deck.

Common website redesign mistakes growing teams make

After dozens of redesign projects, the same patterns show up again and again. A few to steer clear of:

• Starting with mood boards, not metrics. Aesthetic decisions should support your revenue goals, not overshadow them. For example, teams sometimes pick a dramatic new color palette that looks great in a deck but makes CTAs harder to see on mobile.
• Ignoring SEO until the end. That’s how high intent pages quietly vanish and organic leads drop.
• Rewriting everything at once. Keep proven copy and structure where it already converts. If a pricing page or product detail page already converts well, start with small, testable changes instead of burning it down.
• Overloading the homepage. It’s not a brochure; it’s a decision tree that routes visitors to the right next step.
• Launching without a rollback or fix plan. Something will break. That’s not failure; it’s a line item to handle.

“The goal of a redesign isn’t a prettier site. It’s a site that does a better job of turning the right visitors into customers.”

How to choose the right partner for your redesign

Some teams can handle a redesign fully in house. Many growing businesses are better off pairing internal knowledge with an external team that lives and breathes performance.

Questions to ask any potential partner:

• How do you tie design decisions to conversion and revenue, not just aesthetics?
• Can you walk us through a past project where you protected or improved SEO performance?
• Who owns strategy, design, dev, and analytics and how do they work together?
• What is fixed (timeline, scope, pricing), and what might change during the project?

Look for partners who talk in terms of experiments, tracking, and ROI. If you’d like that kind of approach, you can see how Setsail handles conversion focused website design and development for growth focused brands.

What happens after launch: test and improve

The day your new site goes live, resist the urge to declare victory. Instead, treat the first 90 days as an optimization window.

• Monitor leading indicators: page speed, error rates, 404s, and tracking accuracy.
• Compare key metrics: conversion rate, bounce rate, form completion, and checkout flow vs. your baseline.
• Run targeted A/B tests: headlines, CTAs, hero layouts, pricing page structure.
• Gather qualitative feedback: sales team notes, support tickets, on site surveys.

A simple 30/60/90 day plan keeps the team focused: stabilize bugs and tracking in week one, tackle obvious UX friction and quick win tests in the first month, then move into deeper experiments like pricing, offers, and navigation changes once traffic and data have normalized.

At Setsail, we often bundle redesigns with paid media or SEO engagements so we can see the whole picture: traffic quality, on site behavior, and revenue together.

‍